Old Saybrook eliminates Canton on penalty kicks

Old Saybrook’s Annalise Sarette consoles Canton goalie McKenzie Yanke as her Ram teammates celebrate beating the Warriors in penalty kicks in Saturday’s Class S quarterfinal. More game photos
OLD SAYBROOK, Nov. 14, 2026 – For 100 minutes, the Canton High girls soccer team battled Old Saybrook on the pitch in Saturday’s Class S quarterfinal contest.
Each team scored two goals. Goalies McKenzie Yanke of Canton and Amarra Holmes of Old Saybrook each had some big saves in net but it was Yanke who was kept busier pulling down shots out of the air and blocking potential game-changing shots.
It came down to penalty kicks.
Old Saybrook converted on their first four penalty kicks to beat the Warriors for the second straight year, 3-2, and advance to next week’s semifinals where they will face No. 2 Lewis Mills. A year ago, the Rams beat Canton in the semifinals, 1-0.
“Penalty kicks are very stressful. Nobody ever wants to experience that. We’ve been practicing them a decent amount. I think were practicing them a little too much,” Old Saybrook coach Lauren Zehnder said. “The girls were starting to resent me a bit. One of them just came over, hugged me and said, Coach thanks for making us practice them.
“It was stressful, exciting. You never want to get to penalty kicks but I’m so proud of them,” she said.
No. 3 Old Saybrook (15-3-4) won the penalty kick phase of the game, 4-2, to advance.
The two teams scored four goals in the first half and went scoreless in the second half, thanks in part to Yanke, who made a variety of tough saves. She came out of the net several times to gobble up loose balls, cut down the angles for the Rams to shoot on net, punch out a corner kick or intercept a pass into the penalty area.
Yanke finished with 11 saves according to the Rams’ scorebook. Seemed like more.
When it was over, the Rams raced onto the field to celebrate with each other. But more than one Old Saybrook player came over to console Yanke, who sat on the grass near the far post of the goal with her head down.
“She has been a rock in the back,” Canton coach Jim Potter said. “She has stopped many one-on-one (scoring opportunities). She goes for it.”

Canton’s Julia Koczak (9) tries to move downfield in Saturday’s Class S quarterfinal game at Old Saybrook. The Rams’ Lindsay Kawecki (2, left) and Arionna Fox (3, right) are trying to slow her down. More game photos
No. 6 Canton (13-5-1) had a 2-1 lead midway through the first half on a pair of goals from All-State forward Julia Koczak. Kayla Berning and Lucy O’Connor had assists on the respective goals.
Those two scores extended Koczak’s school-record mark to 34 goals this season.
Playing with a sense of urgency, the Rams tied the game at 2-2 with 3:50 left in the first half on a goal by freshman Audrey Sarette. Her older sister, captain Annalise Sarette, had the first goal for the Rams.
“We came out a little nervous in the first half,” Zehnder said. “In the second half we were able to control the game and play our style, control the ball with a lot of push forward. We have 11 seniors. They’ve played together for all of these years so they’re very dedicated and really focused.”
Yanke denied them a game-winning goal in the second half.
Just seven minutes into the second half, she tipped a hard shot from Ainsley Sigersmith just over the crossbar.
Twelve minutes into the second half, Yanke collied with two Rams players trying to head the ball into the net.
With under five minutes left, she again tipped another hard Rams shot over the crossbar. With 2:20 remaining, Yanke came out of her net to grab the ball on a crossing shot before a Rams player could get their foot on the ball.
Canton defender Ally Wire stopped two Old Saybrook breakaway attempts by getting in the way and moving the ball off to the side.
The Warriors had a few corner kicks and opportunities in the second half but one of their best chances came in the second 10-minute overtime session when Koczak blasted a shot that hit the top of the crossbar and dribbled over the bar.
An inch lower and it could have been Canton moving on.

Canton goalie McKenzie Yanke, left, tries to grab the ball before Old Saybrook’s Claire Cassella (6, center) and Annalise Sarette (8, right) can get their head on the ball in Saturday’s Class S quarterfinal. More game photos
In the penalty kicks, it was tied 1-1 after the first round but Holmes made two saves to give the Rams a 3-1 lead after three rounds. In round four, freshman Lucy O’Connor converted for the Warriors but Claire Cassella scored for Old Saybrook to clinch the match.
“They had a good season,” Potter said. “It is just unfortunate. No one likes to go to PKs.
“I think it was a good battle for us. I don’t think we were that outmatched,” he said. “We just had a couple of lapses in the first half. We weren’t paying attention and that is all it takes.”
Old Saybrook 3, Canton 2, penalty kicks
At Old Saybrook
Canton (13-5-1) 2 0 0 0 — 2
Old Saybrook (15-3-4) 2 0 0 0 — 2
Goals: Julia Koczak (C) 2, Annalise Sarette (OS), Audrey Sarette (OS); Assist: Kayla Berning (C); Saves: McKenzie Yanke (C) 11, Amarra Holmes (OS) 7; Penalty kicks goals: Kozak (C), Lucy O’Connor (C); Kaitlin Kawecki (OS), Arionna Fox (OS), Annalise Sarett (OS), Claire Cassella (OS); Of note: Winner advances to semifinals
NCCC standings 2026
| Team | Lg | Overall |
| Suffield | 10-0 | 13-3 |
| Rockville | 7-2-1 | 8-7-1 |
| Canton | 6-3-1 | 11-4-1 |
| Coventry | 6-3-1 | 11-4-1 |
| Granby | 5-2-2 | 11-3-2 |