Old Saybrook prevails in OT to eliminate Lewis Mills in semifinals

The Lewis Mills girls soccer team faced Old Saybrook in Tuesday night’s Class S semifinal in Naugatuck. (Photo courtesy Steve Barlow)
By STEVE BARLOW
Special to The Collinsville Press
NAUGATUCK, Oct. 17, 2026 – For the second straight season, the Lewis Mills girls soccer team tasted heartache in the state semifinals. For the second straight time, the Spartans had the better of things everywhere except on the scoreboard.
Old Saybrook, which trailed at halftime after being unable to dent Mills’ back row, evened the score in the second half and then scored twice in overtime to end the Spartans’ season, 3-1, at chilly Naugatuck High in Tuesday’s Class S semifinals.
The third-seeded Rams (16-3-3) will return to the state championship game this weekend against top-seeded Stonington. Old Saybrook, which fell to Morgan a year ago in the final, will try to become the fourth straight Shoreline Conference team to win a Class S state championship.
No. 2 Lewis Mills (12-5-2) saw its season end one game short of its ultimate goal and did so in similar fashion to the previous year.
Just as in a 1-0 Class M semifinal loss to Northwest Catholic in 2025, the Spartans again had far more scoring chances, outshooting the Rams, 17-8, but couldn’t convert enough.
After a loss that stung, coach Quentin Lux had to deliver a speech he didn’t prepare for.
“I didn’t plan on having that conversation with them tonight,” Lux said. “I’m sure they believed we had a good chance to move on and continue.”
At halftime, it looked like Mills, the 2024 Class M champion, had an excellent chance to advance to its second state final in three seasons.
In a hard-fought contest, the Spartans owned a 1-0 lead. With exactly 9:00 on the clock, winger Taylor Hatt took a pass from London Meadows and blasted a shot from the right side past Rams keeper Amarra Holmes.
Mills continued to put pressure on Old Saybrook’s defense in the second half, but with 23:44 left to play, the Rams got the equalizer. Striker Annalise Sarette took a throw-in from Ainsley Sigersmith and rocketed a shot from the right corner that sailed over leaping Mills keeper Liza Putnam to tie the score.
“I knew we needed a goal because we were down,” Sarette said. “I just shot it and it went in. I think that changed the game.”
Actually, Mills continued to enjoy an edge in possession time, but couldn’t get the go-ahead goal. The most tantalizing opportunity was a header by Hatt off a Sadie Aston corner kick that just curved wide with 4:30 left.
“We re-emphasized our plan to go forward when we got the ball, being direct at times and looking to finish every play off, whether with a shot, a corner, a free kick or whatever,” Lux said. “We did go to two strikers at some points as well, which helped to create chances. Unfortunately, we just weren’t able to finish and get a bigger lead.”

Old Saybrook’s Ainsley Sigermith (10), shown in Saturday’s Class S quarterfinal, had a goal in Tuesday’s Class S semifinal.
After a scoreless first overtime period, Old Saybrook broke through with 5:39 on the clock in the second OT. Again, it was Sarette scoring off a pass from Sigersmith. She launched a shot from 30 yards out that Putnam initially stopped, but the ball popped out of her grasp and bounced in.
“Last round (a 3-2 quarterfinal win over Canton), we went to (penalty kicks). I did not want to go to PKs again,” Sarette said. “I was trying everything in my power to get a goal. I just shot it to see what happens.”
Less than a minute later, the Rams cemented the victory as Sigersmith took a pass from Arionna Fox in the box and booted in an insurance goal.
Holmes made 12 saves in goal for Old Saybrook, which has 13 seniors, while Putnam had four for Mills, which will lose seven seniors.
“There’s a lot to be proud of,” Lux said. “The seniors that have been here since freshman year have been to four state semis in a row, were champions their sophomore year. So, there’s a lot to be proud of. And I told them we’ll be back. We’ve got a good core for next year. There’s a lot to learn from tonight, but we’ll be back.”
Old Saybrook 3, Lewis Mills 1
At Naugatuck
Old Saybrook (16-3-3) 0 1 0 2 – 3
Lewis Mills (12-5-2) 1 0 0 0 – 1
Goals: LM – Taylor Hatt; OS – Annalise Sarette 2, Ainsley Sigersmith 1. Assists: LM – London Meadows 1. OS – Sigersmith 2, Arionna Fox 1. Saves: LM – Putnam 4; OS – Amarra Holmes 12.